Apolyton Archive  |  Preserved copy of the Apolyton Civilization Site forums as they ran on Ultimate Bulletin Board, 1998–2001. Read-only; nothing here can be posted to or replied to.  |  Forum index |  About this archive |  The 2005 site & forums

  Apolyton Civilization Site Forums
  Civ3-General/Suggestions
  Completely new idea for city management

Post New Topic  Post A ReplyPost A Reply In A New Window

profile | register | preferences | faq | search next newest topic | next oldest topic bottom of page
Author
Topic:   Completely new idea for city management Format for Better Printing
AzNtoccata
Settler

Jan 2001
posted January 14, 2001 01:03   Click Here to See the Profile for AzNtoccataClick Here to Email AzNtoccata  send a private message to AzNtoccata
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
While it would be realistic, I don't know whether it'll make the game boring or not. I think that you should "zone" houses, factories, farms etc which slowly build over time. Houses house people (duh!) farms produce food then fill houses with people (more duh!). Terrain is still important because if you build farms on grassland, it'll produce more than on a mountain. For building stuff in a city, I think you should be able to build more than 1 stuff and then assign people and resources to the different projects. Governments play an important role in this cause while a Republic might be more free (scientific advancement), you can't "force" as many people to work on government projects than say...communism. I think this is a great idea and solves many problems that people don't like. Feedback?
AzNtoccata
Settler

Jan 2001
posted January 14, 2001 01:13   Click Here to See the Profile for AzNtoccataClick Here to Email AzNtoccata  send a private message to AzNtoccata
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
All right, I thought of some basic city buildings down (not improvements)

Houses: Houses population, basically functions as aqueduct sorta thing

Farms: do food, basically feeds and expandes population

Factories: actually putting the people into government work (you can only assign some factories to do work for you, others are private. Has to do with the government prob I mentioned earlier). Basically the blender that mixes resources from mines and people from houses into the good 'ol shields that can go into various projects

Mines: Collects resources and sent to factory

Marketplace: collects "trade". I know it sounds weird but marketplace collects the trade both from the terrain and from toher cities

Bank (money center? whatever?): converts trade into $$$. Basically limits how much of trade you can turn into hard cash

Reserearch center: same as bank cept for beakers

Theatre: same as bank cept for goblets

As you research stuff, you upgrade (should be automatic to save trouble, but occurs over time) building to be more effective. such as improving simple marketplaces to the modern commercial skyscrapers we know and love and from simple mud huts to the apartment buildings.
These are the basics, maybe add barracks to limit how much units you can build or something but I think i got basics down

AzNtoccata
Settler

Jan 2001
posted January 14, 2001 01:33   Click Here to See the Profile for AzNtoccataClick Here to Email AzNtoccata  send a private message to AzNtoccata
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
I'll organize my thoughts into one huge organized essay later. Sorry for messiness, but when you get great ideas, get them down before you forget =).
AzNtoccata
Settler

Jan 2001
posted January 14, 2001 01:44   Click Here to See the Profile for AzNtoccataClick Here to Email AzNtoccata  send a private message to AzNtoccata
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
I think that this is the greatest idea so far from city management. Earlier posts only complain about things but don't try and solve it.

oh btw: my idea creates diversity in the types of building you build in each square. If you cluster all your homes in 1 tile and the enemy comes along and occupies it, suddenly your factories don't have any more workers. I support the refugee idea propsed earlier. When large number of people are displaced by destruction of houses, refugees are created.

DarkCloud
King
of Clouds
Jul 2000
posted January 15, 2001 18:53   Click Here to See the Profile for DarkCloudClick Here to Email DarkCloud  send a private message to DarkCloud Visit DarkCloud's Homepage!
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
AzN, abou the city management zoning, good idea and more like real life.
Each zoning would cost money on the city screen; this would make better
use for the city screen.
You would zone for
a: Homes (Luxury, Medial, Cheapo)
b: Stores (Large, Small)
c: Industry (Heavy, Medial, Light)

Zoning is a perfect new idea- good work AzNtoccata!

Urban Ranger
Emperor
The City State of Noosphere
May 99
posted January 15, 2001 23:19   Click Here to See the Profile for Urban RangerClick Here to Email Urban Ranger  send a private message to Urban Ranger
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Not sure if that should be implemented. If we need to manage each of the cities like SimCity it would be a micromanagement nightmare!
bagdar
Chieftain
Turkey
Jan 2001
posted January 16, 2001 16:41   Click Here to See the Profile for bagdar   send a private message to bagdar
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
quote:

Originally posted by Urban Ranger on 01-15-2001 11:19 PM
If we need to manage each of the cities like SimCity it would be a micromanagement nightmare!

I agree, with Civ you can't go that far as to planning where the houses go! Besides, a city improvement called "house" just doesn't sound right. No multiple sim-cities.

Brent
Chieftain

Dec 2000
posted January 16, 2001 17:15   Click Here to See the Profile for BrentClick Here to Email Brent  send a private message to Brent
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Well I do think that at least you should be able to build more than one of the same improvement in one city, which I thought you meant at first, but you also should be able to build more than one thing at a time.
Sirotnikov
Prince
Israel
Feb 2000
posted January 16, 2001 17:38   Click Here to See the Profile for SirotnikovClick Here to Email Sirotnikov  send a private message to SirotnikovSend a Message to UIN: 18345800
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Zoning doen't have to require one to actually have a little city map and mark squares!

You can simply adjust a slider that would mark how much goes into building residential, how much into industri and how much into stores.

This is important since you can then specialize cities!

I think this should be added to every city screen.

Brent
Chieftain

Dec 2000
posted January 16, 2001 17:50   Click Here to See the Profile for BrentClick Here to Email Brent  send a private message to Brent
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
It's a nice thought, but too simple compared to what we're used to.
tniem
Warlord
Grand Rapids
Apr 2000
posted January 16, 2001 20:36   Click Here to See the Profile for tniemClick Here to Email tniem  send a private message to tniem Visit tniem's Homepage!
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
quote:

Originally posted by Sirotnikov on 01-16-2001 05:38 PM
You can simply adjust a slider that would mark how much goes into building residential, how much into industri and how much into stores.

This is important since you can then specialize cities!

I think this should be added to every city screen.

Always like an idea that uses sliders.

But to Civ mixed with SimCity - Firaxis wouldn't dare...

Diablo, Bro. of Mephisto
Prince
Salt Lake City, USA
Oct 2000
posted January 18, 2001 19:38   Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo, Bro. of MephistoClick Here to Email Diablo, Bro. of Mephisto  send a private message to Diablo, Bro. of Mephisto
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Not to be rude or anything, but this WAS talked about a while back, but good idea to bring it up again.

I like the idea of 'zoning' buildings. Maybe you could put different buildings in different areas, for example:

government area: 1. capital building. 2. government building. these two would be different, the latter would be the main offices, the civs memory home (a bunch of memory stuff to keep the spirit alive, it would include historical stuff that that civ did), your 'throne room' would be here too. the government building would have the House of Representatives and senate chambers (if playing with a democracy or republic), the high council chambers, etc.

residential areas: 1. houses. 2. parks, recreation centers, etc. the latter would (of course) house the people. the parks and such would be the stuff that kept the people happy.

then there would also be a 'military' compound area, and a bussiness area.

MrFun
Prince
United States, Iowa
Nov 2000
posted January 18, 2001 20:36   Click Here to See the Profile for MrFun   send a private message to MrFun Visit MrFun's Homepage!
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Sounds like some of you want to add more and more complexity to the game and thus taking away the fun of the game.

That is my opinion, anyways.

tniem
Warlord
Grand Rapids
Apr 2000
posted January 20, 2001 16:05   Click Here to See the Profile for tniemClick Here to Email tniem  send a private message to tniem Visit tniem's Homepage!
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
quote:

Originally posted by MrFun on 01-18-2001 08:36 PM
Sounds like some of you want to add more and more complexity to the game and thus taking away the fun of the game.

That is my opinion, anyways.

Never understand why complexity detracts from the fun.

I personally do not want to have to zone my cities or tell them how to grow, but if Firaxis were to do it in a responsible way then it might be fun.

Brent
Chieftain

Dec 2000
posted January 21, 2001 02:01   Click Here to See the Profile for BrentClick Here to Email Brent  send a private message to Brent
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
probably for the same reason that nobody likes games to be challenging, eh?
Yog-Sothoth
Warlord
Trondheim, Norway
Sep 2000
posted January 21, 2001 07:10   Click Here to See the Profile for Yog-SothothClick Here to Email Yog-Sothoth  send a private message to Yog-SothothSend a Message to UIN: 83769383
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
quote:

Originally posted by Brent on 01-21-2001 02:01 AM
probably for the same reason that nobody likes games to be challenging, eh?

I want my civ game to be challenging, but I want it to challenge my intellect by f.e. having great AI, not challenge my patience by making me play mini-Sim City on every city in my civ game.

Diablo, Bro. of Mephisto
Prince
Salt Lake City, USA
Oct 2000
posted January 24, 2001 20:19   Click Here to See the Profile for Diablo, Bro. of MephistoClick Here to Email Diablo, Bro. of Mephisto  send a private message to Diablo, Bro. of Mephisto
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
You are right, I dont want to be playing Sim-city either. Although you do have to admit, there is pride with you seeing a city YOU built that is absolutely humungous, and awesome.
Grumbold
Warlord
London, UK
Mar 2000
posted January 25, 2001 06:55   Click Here to See the Profile for Grumbold   send a private message to Grumbold
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Micromanaging every city would indeed be a nightmare but I would quite like this idea if it was done for your capital only. How you designed it could reflect on general happiness, efficiency, education, military, crime and pollution modifiers for your empire as a whole. The only drawback is that anything which increases the length of a turn is going to make Multiplayer less playable at the expense of 1 player / PBEM.
Apolyton Civilization Site Forums
> > > Civ3-General/Suggestions Forum

next newest topic | next oldest topictop of page

All times are EDT

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic | Top
Post New Topic  Post A ReplyPost A Reply In A New Window
Hop to:

Contact Us
Apolyton Civilization Site

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.44a
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.

Front Page | Civilization III | Dinosaurs | Civilization II | Call to Power | Call to Power II | Alpha Centauri | Alternative Civs | Misc | Links | About ACS | GameStats
GameLeague | Scenario League | HAC | Civilization Scenario Collection | Spanish CivII Site | Clash of Civs | CtP Maps | Art of War | WesW's Ctp1/2 Site