Apolyton Archive  |  Preserved copy of the Apolyton Civilization Site forums as they ran on Ultimate Bulletin Board, 1998–2001. Read-only; nothing here can be posted to or replied to.  |  Forum index |  About this archive |  The 2005 site & forums

Thread Closed  Thread Closed
  Apolyton Civilization Site Forums
  Civ3-The List of Ideas for Firaxis
  EC3 New Ideas - Voting Thread (Page 2)

Post New Topic  

This topic is 3 pages long:   1  2  3 

profile | register | preferences | faq | search

 next newest topic | next oldest topic bottom of page
Author Topic:   EC3 New Ideas - Voting Thread            Current Date/Time: March 24, 2000 19:34:31
kcbob
Chieftain
From: Kansas City, MO USA
Registered: Dec 1999
posted March 11, 2000 11:00   Click Here to See the Profile for kcbobClick Here to Email kcbob Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #3 - Hex Based Map
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory
New Idea #15 - Religion
slamp
Prince
From: The Hague - The Netherlands
Registered: Sep 1999
posted March 11, 2000 14:09   Click Here to See the Profile for slampClick Here to Email slampVisit slamp's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


My vote:
New Idea #3 - Hex Based Map
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory
New Idea #15 - Religion

But I also like:
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities
New Idea #13 - Recruitment System
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #4 - Tourism
New Idea #1 - Open Source AI

Qualiciide
Chieftain
From: victor NY, USA
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 11, 2000 15:09   Click Here to See the Profile for QualiciideClick Here to Email QualiciideVisit Qualiciide's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#4
#6
#9
#12
#15
Gearyman
Settler
From: Pensacola, FL
Registered: Feb 2000
posted March 11, 2000 17:27   Click Here to See the Profile for GearymanClick Here to Email GearymanVisit Gearyman's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #3 - Hex Based Map
New Idea #4 - Tourism
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities
Jon Miller
Warlord
From:
Registered: May 99
posted March 11, 2000 21:03   Click Here to See the Profile for Jon MillerClick Here to Email Jon Miller Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


as of right now 5,6,11

and I don't think this will do anything but distract us for a while

Jon Miller

CyberGnu
Prince
From: The Serengeti
Registered: Apr 99
posted March 11, 2000 21:24   Click Here to See the Profile for CyberGnuClick Here to Email CyberGnuVisit CyberGnu's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


# 6
# 7
# 8
# 9
# 15 (But maybe this should be optional...)


[This message has been edited by CyberGnu (edited March 11, 2000).]

Youngsun
Chieftain
From: Darwin,NT,Australia
Registered: Jan 2000
posted March 12, 2000 00:38   Click Here to See the Profile for YoungsunClick Here to Email Youngsun Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#2
#4
#6
#8
#11
Sir Shiva
Settler
From: Bangalore, INDIA
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 12, 2000 04:35   Click Here to See the Profile for Sir ShivaClick Here to Email Sir ShivaVisit Sir Shiva's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea#15 - Religion
New Idea#11 - Domestic Politics
New Idea#8 - Energy
New Idea#7 - Stacking
New Idea#4 - Tourism
Blade Runner
Warlord
From: Belgium
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 12, 2000 06:06   Click Here to See the Profile for Blade RunnerClick Here to Email Blade Runner Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


1 - Open Source AI
2 - Detailed Replay
7 - Stacking
9 - Expanding City Radius
14 - New Modes of Victory

[This message has been edited by Blade Runner (edited March 12, 2000).]
S. Kroeze
Chieftain
From: the Hague, the Netherlands
Registered: Dec 1999
posted March 12, 2000 07:30   Click Here to See the Profile for S. KroezeClick Here to Email S. Kroeze Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea # 6 - Rise and Fall of Empires
New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
New Idea #13 - Recruitment System
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory
New Idea #15 - Religion
Sparky
Warlord
From: Ohio
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 12, 2000 10:28   Click Here to See the Profile for SparkyClick Here to Email Sparky Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


2-detailed replay
7-stacking (for group movement and battle)
15-religion
9-expanding city radius
14-new modes of victory
Chowlett
Chieftain
From: Troon, Scotland, UK
Registered: May 99
posted March 12, 2000 10:47   Click Here to See the Profile for ChowlettClick Here to Email ChowlettVisit Chowlett's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


4 - Tourism
6 - Rise & Fall
11 - Domestic Politics
14 - New Victories
15 - Religion
Grigger
Warlord
From: CT
Registered: Jul 1999
posted March 12, 2000 14:00   Click Here to See the Profile for Grigger  Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#3 - Hex Based Map
#4 - Tourism
#6 - Rise and Fall
#14 - New Victories
#15 - Religion
[This message has been edited by Grigger (edited March 12, 2000).]
John the kicked
Settler
From:
Registered: Aug 1999
posted March 12, 2000 15:35   Click Here to See the Profile for John the kicked  Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory
Mercani
Settler
From: Newark, DE, USA
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 12, 2000 17:08   Click Here to See the Profile for Mercani  Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only



New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities
Adm.Naismith
Warlord
From: Milano - Italy
Registered: Oct 1999
posted March 12, 2000 17:13   Click Here to See the Profile for Adm.Naismith  Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #13 - Recruitment System

------------------
Adm.Naismith AKA mcostant

KoenigMkII
Settler
From: St. Helier, Jersey, United Kingdom
Registered: Apr 99
posted March 12, 2000 17:45   Click Here to See the Profile for KoenigMkIIClick Here to Email KoenigMkII Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


3 - Hex based Map
7 - Stacking
9 - Expanding city radius
5 - Simultaneous turns of play
8 - Energy
Mark_Everson
Clash of Civilizations
Project Lead
From: Canton, MI, USA
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 12, 2000 18:26   Click Here to See the Profile for Mark_EversonClick Here to Email Mark_EversonVisit Mark_Everson's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
sanantonio
Settler
From:
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 12, 2000 18:37   Click Here to See the Profile for sanantonio  Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #15 - Religion
dchill2
Settler
From: Boyds, MD, USA
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 12, 2000 23:29   Click Here to See the Profile for dchill2Click Here to Email dchill2 Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #13 - Recruitment System
New Idea #15 - Religion
LordGrey
Chieftain
From: Born in Syracuse, NY, now in Philadelphia, PA USA
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 12, 2000 23:33   Click Here to See the Profile for LordGreyClick Here to Email LordGrey Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory
New Idea #15 - Religion
Tiberius
Chieftain
From: Romania
Registered: Jan 2000
posted March 13, 2000 01:40   Click Here to See the Profile for TiberiusClick Here to Email Tiberius Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #4 - Tourism
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory
landshark
Settler
From: Minneapolis, MN
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 13, 2000 09:25   Click Here to See the Profile for landsharkClick Here to Email landshark Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #3 - Hex Based Map
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities
MadWoodster
Chieftain
From: Southampton
Registered: Jan 2000
posted March 13, 2000 11:39   Click Here to See the Profile for MadWoodsterClick Here to Email MadWoodsterVisit MadWoodster's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


In order

1) New idea #8 Energy
2) New idea #9 Expanding City Radius
3) New idea #10 Automatic Patrolling
4) New idea #1 Open source AI
5) New idea #3 Hex Based Map

Joe Bourque
Settler
From: Orono, ME, USA
Registered: Feb 2000
posted March 13, 2000 12:01   Click Here to See the Profile for Joe Bourque  Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#2.) Detailed Replay
#3.) Hex Based Map
#6.) Rise and Fall of Empires
#11.) Domestic Politics
#15.) Religion
Volospin
Settler
From: Columbus, Ohio, USA
Registered: Feb 2000
posted March 13, 2000 13:15   Click Here to See the Profile for VolospinClick Here to Email Volospin Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#6 - Rise and fall of Empires
#11 - Domestic Politics
#15 - Religion
#7 - Stacking
#4 - Tourism
Abilard
Settler
From: Atlanta, GA, USA
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 13, 2000 13:44   Click Here to See the Profile for AbilardClick Here to Email AbilardVisit Abilard's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#7 -Stacking
#11-Domestic Politics
#13-Rectuitment System
#8 -Energy
#15-Religion
don Don
King
From: It's too hot here.
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 13, 2000 17:59   Click Here to See the Profile for don DonClick Here to Email don DonVisit don Don's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


  • New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
  • New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
  • New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
  • New Idea #3 - Hex Based Map
  • New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
Can we vote against ones we absolutely never, ever want to see anywhere near Civ3?
Slax
Warlord
From: London, Ontario, Canada
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 13, 2000 18:10   Click Here to See the Profile for SlaxClick Here to Email SlaxVisit Slax's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


# 1
# 6
# 7
# 8
#12
SnowFire
King
From: Absecon, New Jersey
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 13, 2000 18:43   Click Here to See the Profile for SnowFireClick Here to Email SnowFire Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#1 - Open Source AI
#2 - Detailed Replay
#11 - Domestic Politics

Oh yes, and if you can make "anti-votes," then I vote against New Modes of Victory and Rise and Fall of Empires with my two remaining votes.

[This message has been edited by SnowFire (edited March 13, 2000).]

Shiva
Settler
From: Omaha,Nebraska USA
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 13, 2000 19:38   Click Here to See the Profile for ShivaClick Here to Email Shiva Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#1 - Open source AI
#3 - Hex based map
#5 - Simultaneous turns of play
#8 - Energy
#13 - Recruitment system
Napoleon I
Settler
From: Los Angeles
Registered: Feb 2000
posted March 13, 2000 21:18   Click Here to See the Profile for Napoleon IClick Here to Email Napoleon I Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea # 6 - Rise and fall of empires
New Idea # 8 - Energy
New Idea # 11 - Domestic politics
New Idea # 12 - Different levels of cities
New Idea # 14 - New modes of victory

------------------
Napoleon I

Matthevv
Chieftain
From: Crawley, W.Sussex, England
Registered: Mar 99
posted March 14, 2000 08:40   Click Here to See the Profile for MatthevvClick Here to Email Matthevv Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


1. Open source AI
6. Rise and fall of empires
7. Stacking
11. Domestic politics
15. Religion
Papa Bass
Settler
From: Germany
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 14, 2000 11:36   Click Here to See the Profile for Papa BassClick Here to Email Papa Bass Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


Votes: 3
5
8
9
11

But I have 2 more suggestions which would improve the game a lot:
1. Borders (there have to be borders which are defined between two neighbor countries by negotiations, which leads to point
2. More diplomacy (different alliances, embargos,...)


[This message has been edited by Papa Bass (edited March 14, 2000).]

Rathenn
Settler
From: Melbourne, Australia
Registered: May 99
posted March 14, 2000 17:40   Click Here to See the Profile for RathennClick Here to Email Rathenn Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
New Idea #4 - Tourism
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities
jgv_fiera
Settler
From: Spain
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 14, 2000 19:20   Click Here to See the Profile for jgv_fieraClick Here to Email jgv_fieraVisit jgv_fiera's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


1- Rise and Fall of Empires
2- Religion
3- Recruitment System
4- Hex Based Map
5- Different Levels of Cities
mikellos
Settler
From: Hungary
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 14, 2000 20:08   Click Here to See the Profile for mikellosClick Here to Email mikellos Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities
New Idea #14 - New Modes of Victory

Deathlock
Settler
From: Oshawa,Ontario,Cnada
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 14, 2000 21:05   Click Here to See the Profile for DeathlockClick Here to Email Deathlock Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


i pick

New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #7 - Stacking


Deathlock
Settler
From: Oshawa,Ontario,Cnada
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 14, 2000 21:06   Click Here to See the Profile for DeathlockClick Here to Email Deathlock Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


i pick

New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
New Idea #5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #7 - Stacking


Civ_Lover1701
Settler
From:
Registered: Feb 2000
posted March 15, 2000 00:29   Click Here to See the Profile for Civ_Lover1701Click Here to Email Civ_Lover1701 Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #3 - Hex Based Map
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities

Sophanthro
Prince
From: Allentown,PA,USA
Registered: Jul 1999
posted March 15, 2000 02:10   Click Here to See the Profile for SophanthroClick Here to Email Sophanthro Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#1 Open Source AI
#2 Detailed Replay
#7 Stacking
#14 New Modes of Victory
#11 Domestic Policies
DirkZelwis
Settler
From: Berlin, Germany, Europa
Registered: Feb 2000
posted March 15, 2000 02:39   Click Here to See the Profile for DirkZelwisClick Here to Email DirkZelwis Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#3 Hex Based Map
#5 Simultaneous Turns
#6 Rise and Fall of Empires
#14 New Modes of Victory
jwhin281
Settler
From: Houston, Tx USA
Registered: Oct 1999
posted March 15, 2000 08:03   Click Here to See the Profile for jwhin281Click Here to Email jwhin281 Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


#4 Tourism
#9 Expanded City Radius
#11 Domestic Politics
#12 Different Levels of Cities
#14 New Modes of Victory
Hex
Settler
From: Mänttä, Finland
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 15, 2000 08:41   Click Here to See the Profile for HexClick Here to Email Hex Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #15 - Religion
New Idea #2 - Detailed Replay
New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
Temudschin
Settler
From: Stolberg, NRW, Germany
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 15, 2000 09:14   Click Here to See the Profile for TemudschinClick Here to Email TemudschinVisit Temudschin's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #15 - Religion
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #6 - Rise and fall of Empires
New Idea #7 - Stacking
New Idea #4 - Tourism

------------------
The ruler of the known world
Temudschin Dschingis Khan

Yttrium
Settler
From: Golden Valley,MN
Registered: Mar 2000
posted March 15, 2000 11:14   Click Here to See the Profile for YttriumClick Here to Email Yttrium Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #3 - Hex Based Maps
New Idea #4 - Tourism
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #11 - Domestic Politics
New Idea #15 - Religion
mwpolen
Settler
From: leesburg,va
Registered: Jul 1999
posted March 15, 2000 15:17   Click Here to See the Profile for mwpolenClick Here to Email mwpolen Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
6 - Rise and fall of Empires
7 - Stacking
9 - Expanding City Radius
8 - Energy
mwpolen
Settler
From: leesburg,va
Registered: Jul 1999
posted March 15, 2000 15:17   Click Here to See the Profile for mwpolenClick Here to Email mwpolen Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


5 - Simultaneous Turns of Play
6 - Rise and fall of Empires
7 - Stacking
9 - Expanding City Radius
8 - Energy
Notech
Settler
From: Vernamo, Sweden
Registered: Dec 1999
posted March 16, 2000 02:16   Click Here to See the Profile for NotechClick Here to Email NotechVisit Notech's Homepage! Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


New Idea #1 - Open Source AI
New Idea #8 - Energy
New Idea #9 - Expanding City Radius
New Idea #10 - Automatic Patrolling
New Idea #12 - Different Levels of Cities

------------------

mzilikazi
Warlord
From: London
Registered: b.02-15-99
posted March 16, 2000 06:29   Click Here to See the Profile for mzilikaziClick Here to Email mzilikazi Edit/Delete Message Reply To & Quote Message IP: Logged, Admin Access Only


1. New modes of victory
2. Detailed replay
3. Stacking
4. Rise & fall of empires
5. Domestic politics

Please don't make it a hex-map...

Apolyton Civilization Site Forums
> > > Civ3-The List of Ideas for Firaxis Forum
This topic is 3 pages long:   1  2  3 		next newest topic | next oldest topictop of page

All times are EDT
Administrative Options: Open Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic   Contact Us
Apolyton Civilization Site
Hop to:

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.44a
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.

Front Page | Civilization III | Dinosaurs | Civilization II | Call to Power | Call to Power II | Alpha Centauri | Alternative Civs | Misc | Links | About ACS | GameStats
GameLeague | Scenario League | Hodadian Award Central | Civilization Scenario Collection | Spanish CivII Site | Clash of Civs | CtP Maps