Apolyton Archive  |  Preserved copy of the Apolyton Civilization Site forums as they ran on Ultimate Bulletin Board, 1998–2001. Read-only; nothing here can be posted to or replied to.  |  Forum index |  About this archive |  The 2005 site & forums

  Apolyton Civilization Site Forums
  CtP2-General
  Submarines and the 'flanking' idea...

Post New Topic  Post A ReplyPost A Reply In A New Window

profile | register | preferences | faq | search next newest topic | next oldest topic bottom of page
Author
Topic:   Submarines and the 'flanking' idea... Format for Better Printing
Phalanx2000
Settler
Dallas Tejas
Dec 2000
posted December 07, 2000 08:30   Click Here to See the Profile for Phalanx2000Click Here to Email Phalanx2000  send a private message to Phalanx2000
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Ok, first off, I'm not much of a txt-file hacker so don't kill me with such... yet...

Why don't submarines have the ability to flank an opposing surface or submarine ship? I can easily imagine a wolf-pack of subs all firing torps at a target simultaneously. Is there a way around this limitation? I was so discouraged by that fact that I've not checked to see if a wolf-pack of nuclear subs or morays will do what I want (when I gained them later). Anybody know?

Packs of subs like that used to be the BANE of an opposing navy's existence. I just hate to see it non-functional....

Carrion
Chieftain
CA
Nov 2000
posted December 07, 2000 09:23   Click Here to See the Profile for CarrionClick Here to Email Carrion  send a private message to Carrion
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
I don't think Subs would make very good flankers. They are very slow when submerged. At least the early subs. Not up to snuff with nuclear subs capabalities. But I think PT boats would be a good candidate for this catergory. But then again i can imagine any naval ship opening up on one target. Anybody remember the Bizmark? Half of the British navy bombarded that ship for hours till it finally sank.
wheathin
Prince
Charming
Apr 99
posted December 07, 2000 10:13   Click Here to See the Profile for wheathinClick Here to Email wheathin  send a private message to wheathin
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
The flank attack only makes sense in the context of a combined fleet attack. But submarines don't work as well when they have to stay in constant contact with other fleet elements. The sub's biggest tactical advantage is stealth and unpredictability - being forced to communicate and follow specific attack orders limits the sub's effectiveness.

Soviet naval doctrine called for subs to support surface assets in this type of role, but that was because Soviet subs were loud, slow, and needed the support of surface ships and aviation to work. American subs have always been more effective when working alone.

The exception is the German wolf pack of WW2. Even there, however, the subs only coordinated with other subs prior to the raids. The attack itself was relatively uncoordinated, preventing any real flanking bonus.

Phalanx2000
Settler
Dallas Tejas
Dec 2000
posted December 08, 2000 08:09   Click Here to See the Profile for Phalanx2000Click Here to Email Phalanx2000  send a private message to Phalanx2000
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
That's interesting... I remember my history (though VERY foggy) as wolf-packs being effective, in fact deadly. But it makes sense that the coordination would be off.

So none of the submerged units in CTP2 flank, huh?

wheathin
Prince
Charming
Apr 99
posted December 08, 2000 09:33   Click Here to See the Profile for wheathinClick Here to Email wheathin  send a private message to wheathin
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
The wolf pack was very deadly against lightly escorted convoys. In those conditions, even uncoordinated packs could savage the defenseless merchantmen.

Note that wolf packs were not used against single ships, and were only instituted when the allies started convoying and Germany was unable to sink as many ships.

Wolf packs themselves became substantially less effective as the allies perfected anti-sub tactics, and as technology gave the advantage to the convoys. Better sonar, more and faster destroyers, and most importantly, escort carriers and increased fighter cover from land bases took a horrendous toll on the U-boats after 1942.

marc420
Chieftain
Atlanta, GA, Amerika
Jun 99
posted December 08, 2000 12:24   Click Here to See the Profile for marc420Click Here to Email marc420  send a private message to marc420
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Doesn't look like something that can be changed in a Txt file anyways. Although I may be wrong. I'm just learning what's in these text files, so I could easily be missing something.

This is in Units.txt

I checked the nuclear sub, and it has a unit category of Category UNIT_CATEGORY_UNDERSEA

Meanwhile the Knight unit has
Category UNIT_CATEGORY_FLANKER

Another unit I checke had UNIT_CATEGORY_ATTACKER

So it looks like "Undersea" is a seperate category from "Flanker" or "Attack" or "Defense" or "Ranged"

Otherwise I was going to try changing these and see how the game played with Subs getting the flank ability.

Phalanx2000
Settler
Dallas Tejas
Dec 2000
posted December 10, 2000 16:21   Click Here to See the Profile for Phalanx2000Click Here to Email Phalanx2000  send a private message to Phalanx2000
Edit/Delete Message    Reply To And Quote This Message
IP: Logged, Admin Access Only
Well, that's cool. Hey, the update on naval tactics was worth it for me!!

I'll go look at those units.txt lines tonight and see what I can find...

Apolyton Civilization Site Forums
> > > CtP2-General Forum

next newest topic | next oldest topictop of page

All times are EDT

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic | Top
Post New Topic  Post A ReplyPost A Reply In A New Window
Hop to:

Contact Us
Apolyton Civilization Site

Powered by: Ultimate Bulletin Board, Version 5.44a
© Infopop Corporation (formerly Madrona Park, Inc.), 1998 - 2000.

AltaVista Type or paste text or Web address (beginning with http://) here:
Powered
by Systran
Translate from: 

Front Page | Civilization III | Dinosaurs | Civilization II | Call to Power | Call to Power II | Alpha Centauri | Alternative Civs | Misc | Links | About ACS | GameStats
GameLeague | Scenario League | HAC | Civilization Scenario Collection | Spanish CivII Site | Clash of Civs | CtP Maps | Art of War | WesW's Ctp1/2 Site